So good, I had to stop reading

“I couldn’t put it down” is common praise for a really good book. It means that the story is so interesting, the characters so compelling that you just have to carry on reading. But have you ever come across a book so good that you had to stop reading? I have.

Last weekend I started The Paper Menagerie by Ken Liu, a collection of literary sci-fi/fantasy stories, almost all of which have been nominated for or won important short story prizes. I got two stories in (or about 25 pages out of 435) and they were so brilliant that I had to put the book down. The stories were ‘The Bookmaking Habits of Select Species’ and ‘State Change’.

the paper menagerie ken liu

The book that moved me.

For a few minutes all I did was stare into space and sigh heavily. Then I told my boyfriend about the story ‘State Change’. Then I went on the website for my local library and added every book Liu has written (and other people’s work he’s translated) to my wishlist. Finally, I got out some cross-stitch because I knew I wasn’t going to get any more reading done that evening.

These are the feelings I had that were so overwhelming I had to stop reading:

  • “I have to think about what I just read.”
  • “How on earth did he come up with those ideas?”
  • “I knew I’d like this and I can’t believe I didn’t pick it up sooner.”
  • “I will never be able to read those stories for the first time again.”
  • “I want this book to last as long as possible.”
  • “I am jealous that I can’t write like this.”
  • “I am so excited to read the rest.”
  • “I am scared to read the rest, because it might not be as good.”
  • “My heart hurts.”

the paper menagerie ken liu

My copy arrived signed by the author!

All in all, that half hour of reading had a pretty awesome emotional and physical impact on me (I could feel a lump in the back of my throat). I don’t know if the rest of the collection is going to live up to those first two stories, but it probably doesn’t matter. A reading experience like that – where you read just the right thing at just the right time for you – is rare, and I’m so lucky that it happened to me.


Have you ever read anything so good you had to put it down? Leave a comment down below – I’d love to know!

You can buy The Paper Menagerie from the Book Depository.

What do you think?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.